Sudden Infant Death or Murder? A Royal Confusion About Probabilities
نویسنده
چکیده
In this article I criticize the recommendations of some prominent statisticians about how to estimate and compare probabilities of the repeated sudden infant death and repeated murder. The issue has drawn considerable public attention in connection with several recent court cases in the UK. I try to show that when the three components of the Bayesian inference are carefully analyzed in this context, the advice of the statisticians turns out to be problematic in each of the steps.
منابع مشابه
Assessing evidence and testing appropriate hypotheses.
It is crucial to identify the most appropriate hypotheses if one is to apply probabilistic reasoning to evaluate and properly understand the impact of evidence. Subtle changes to the choice of a prosecution hypothesis can result in drastically different posterior probabilities to a defence hypothesis from the same evidence. To illustrate the problem we consider a real case in which probabilisti...
متن کاملSally Clark case revisited : another key statistical oversight
The Sally Clark case was notorious for the prosecution’s misuse of statistics in respect of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). In particular, the claim made by Roy Meadows at the original trial – that there was “only 1 in 73 million chance of both children being SIDS victims” – has been thoroughly, and rightly, discredited. However, as made clear by probability experts who analysed the case, ...
متن کاملNeed for a working classification system for sudden and unexpected infant deaths.
Since the 1980s, the rate of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) has declined worldwide; this is largely attributed to “Back to Sleep” campaigns. However, concurrently, there have been increases in the rates of other sudden and unexpected infant deaths (SUIDs), and the overall SUID rate has not improved in the past decade. This “diagnostic shift” is partly due to standardization of, and improve...
متن کاملPrevalence and the Relationship between Characteristics and Parental Conditions with Risk Factors for Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS)
Introduction Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) is a disease which causes unexpected death of infants aged less than 1 year. Given the undeniable role of parents in the presence or absence of SIDS risk factors, the present study aimed to studythe prevalence and the relationship between characteristics and conditions of parent’s infants with SIDS risk factors. Materials and Methods In this cr...
متن کاملSudden Infant Death Syndrome: Risk Factors and the Relationship between Them
Background:Infant mortality is often used as a standard measure of a population’s health. Until cause of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome is unknown (SIDS), the best strategy to decrease SIDS, is programming to decrease facing with risk factors. The aim of this study was to find the SIDS risk factors among families during their child care in Iran. The study is the first in Iran to examine the risk ...
متن کامل